AA 5194 then AA 5857 at Charlotte
Valparaiso → Charlotte → Fayetteville
Timetable, Charlotte time
10:10AA 5194 from Valparaiso at the gate
22:50AA 5857 to Fayetteville leaves the gate
12 h 40 apart on the timetable
AA 5857 leaves 12 h 40 after AA 5194 arrives on the timetable: more than half a day, so not a connection we count.