AA 5586 then AA 2912 at Charlotte
Sarasota → Charlotte → New York LaGuardia
Timetable, Charlotte time
16:57AA 5586 from Sarasota at the gate
16:31AA 2912 to New York LaGuardia leaves the gate
23 h 34 apart on the timetable, overnight
AA 2912 leaves 23 h 34 after AA 5586 arrives on the timetable: more than half a day, so not a connection we count.